There was interest in changing the name of Baranof Elementary even before the last summer’s demonstrations to remove a statue of the 18th Century fur trader from in front of Harrigan Centennial Hall. Although Alexander Baranov was a major figure in Alaska’s colonial history, former Sitka School Board member Dionne Brady-Howard considers him ruthless. “He would have annihilated my ancestors if he had been able to,” she said. (KCAW file photo)

Sitka’s Baranof Elementary School appears likely to have its name changed — but what that new name will be, no one is quite sure yet.

The Sitka School Board recently decided to send the question of the name change to the Sitka Tribe, in hopes of identifying a “significant local cultural educator.”

The hardest part about renaming the Baranof Elementary School will be who to name it for.

At their last meeting on January 6, Sitka School Board members reported that their email was running near 100-percent in favor of naming the building after someone other than the 18th-Century fur trader who, as the first chief manager of the Russian-American Company, was the de facto governor of the Russian colony in North America.

Alexander Baranov’s role in history won’t ever be unwritten. But in her testimony, former school board member Dionne Brady-Howard explained why honoring him with an elementary school remains a bad idea.

“There are some in our town’s history and in our state who have honored his legacy because they view him as an astute businessman,” said Brady-Howard. “However, in establishing that business of sea otter fur exploitation he was ruthless. And he would have annihilated my ancestors if he had been able to.”

There were two major conflicts between indigenous Tlingit and Baranov’s Russians: one in 1802 when the Tlingit destroyed a Russian redoubt at what is now known as Old Sitka; the second in 1804 when Baranov returned with a gunship, and laid siege to Sitka’s Tlingit who had taken refuge in a fort in what is now Sitka National Historical Park, drove them out, captured their village, and built his company headquarters, New Archangel, on its ruins.

It’s this history that makes the current name of the elementary school intolerable to Sitka’s Native community. Muriel Reid put it very bluntly.

“The name Baranof represents the historical trauma deeply rooted in this town,” she said, “and frankly, naming a school after him is a slap in the face to indigenous families in Sitka. It is your job to reduce the amount of environmental racism Sitka families experience within the school.”

Changing the name of Baranof Elementary as a step toward healing gained traction — even before demonstrations last summer pushed the Sitka Assembly to remove a Baranov statue from in front of the centennial building, and place it in the museum inside. Doug Osborne spoke on behalf of the Sitka Community Health Summit coalition working on historical trauma. He offered $3,000 to help cover any costs — such as a facilitated community meeting — that the board might incur during the process. “We’re in this 100-percent,” he told them.

Alaska Native Sisterhood Grand Camp president Paulette Moreno also urged the board to approach the issue deliberately — but not too deliberately.

“I thank you for coming to this,” Moreno said, “and my only advice is that this be a process that is well thought out, well planned — but also it is well overdue.”

So who to name Sitka’s elementary school for? Although it was just a board discussion, attendees had plenty of ideas. Chuck Miller thought back to some of his teachers in the Sitka Native Education program, who propelled him into his own career as an educator:

“…without the teachings of Charlie Joseph, Sr. (Kaal.atk’), Annie Joseph his wife, Annie Dick, my aunt, Elizabeth Basco (Kaat Shi Tlaa) my grandmother, and Emma Duncan Davis — those teachers. And we still have a few of them here: Ethel Mackinen (Daasdiyaa), Ann Johnson (Gooch Tlaa), is another one of our teachers, our elders.”

Laurie Cropley also had some ideas:

“‘Pauline Duncan Elementary School’ I love. Gill Truitt Elementary School. Charlie Joseph Elementary School — there are so many wonderful choices.”

To which Cropley added Isabella Brady and Elizabeth Peratrovich.

Only one board member expressed any reservations about moving forward on this theme. Eric Van Cise was behind changing the name, but didn’t want to necessarily limit the choices.

“That would be my only ask: That along with respected Tlingit names that people have — which I fully support — that we be willing to take this opportunity and collectively think about what we’d like this school to be named.”

Nevertheless, Van Cise did not oppose the final motion, as read by board president Amy Morrison:

“The motion is to formally request the Sitka Tribe of Alaska assist the Sitka School Board in choosing the name of a significant local cultural educator to replace the name of Baranof Elementary School.”

The motion passed unanimously.

Note: This story was updated on 1-16-21 to correct the date of the first major Tlingit/Russian battle at Old Sitka. It occurred in 1802, not 1799 as originally reported.